Women In The Bahaism
One of the most important teaching of bahaism is the gender equality .
But in practice we are facing a contradiction in bahai faith .
Recently I have seen an interesting article written by Dr. Susan S. Maneck entitled ” Women In The Bahai Faith” in the following address
http://women.susanmaneck.com/ .
She is expressing her views in the beginning of her article :
“ The Baha’i faith is the youngest of the world’s religions. Baha’u'llah, the prophet-founder of the Baha’i faith, was born in Iran in 1817. He claimed to be the latest messenger sent by God, an assertion that irremediably separated the Baha’is from their Islamic background. Baha’is believe that while all religions have been ordained by God, the social teachings of religions have varied according to the needs of the age in which a prophet appears. The central theme of the Baha’i message is the establishment of the unity of humankind in a single global society. This necessitates the establishment of a world government, the achievement of universal education, the elimination of all forms of prejudice, and the attainment of full equality of men and women. No other world religion has been quite as explicit as the Baha’i faith in its support of the principle of the equality of men and women. Baha’is themselves proudly assert it as one of the distinguishing features of the new revelation. This equality does not refer solely to the spiritual plane, for Baha’i scriptures explicitly state that there should be “no difference in the education of male and female in order that womankind may develop equal capacity and importance with man in the social and economic equation.” They further assert that “women will enter all the department of politics.” Yet the understanding of this principle varies considerably among Baha’is. Many support a higher evaluation of women’s traditional roles, particularly in family life, but foresee little change in the roles themselves. Others call for a fundamental transformation of the very structure of relations in community life, which would incorporate values from Baha’i scriptures. Regarding family life, the secretary of the Guardian of the Baha’i faith wrote on his behalf: “The task of bringing up a Baha’i child, as emphasized time and again in Baha’i Writings, is the chief responsibility of the mother.” The Universal House of justice, the supreme governing body for the Baha’i world, asserts that the corollary to this is that the financial responsibility for supporting the family rests with the husband. The exclusion of women from the Universal House of justice (which will be discussed later) has tended to perpetuate arguments for “separate but equal spheres” in other realms as well. At the same time, Baha’i ideals for a new world order cannot be attained without a change in societal structures, with women playing a leading role:
The world in the past has been ruled by force, and man has dominated over woman by reason of his more forceful and aggressive qualities both of body and mind. But the balance is already shifting-force is losing its weight and mental alertness, intuition, and the spiritual qualities of love and service, in which woman is strong, are gaining ascendancy. Hence the new age will be an age less masculine, and more permeated with the feminine ideals-or, to speak more exactly, will be an age in which the masculine and feminine elements of civilization will be more evenly balanced.
Many Baha’i women today have tried to hold together all of these statements in the writings by exhibiting the “supermom” syndrome: fulfilling their roles as wives and mothers while attempting to excel in their chosen careers. Needless to say, this doubling of duties creates tremendous stress for these women. Baha’is are often unaware of the historical contexts in which various pronouncements regarding women were made, and this creates great confusion regarding their proper understanding. This issue is confounded by the fact that the development of the Baha’i faith in its early formative period took place in two radically disparate cultures and continents. Originating in Iran in the middle of the nineteenth century, the religion spread to North America in the 1890s. While Baha’i theology was born in the context of a nearly homogeneous Islamic Shi’ite culture, its administrative structure developed in the United States. In the course of this chapter I will trace the role of women within the Baha’i faith from the time of its inception as the Babi movement, through its introduction to the West, until the present time. I will examine both the scriptural status of women as well as the reality of their position within the Baha’i community. While Baha’i communities exist in nearly all countries, I will restrict my discussion to Iran and North America, since sufficient documentation exists only for those two areas, and developments in those religions have largely determined the direction taken by the rest of the Baha’i world. ” . . . . .
Dear Rajah,
I am the author of this article which was posted without my permission. I am hereby notifying you that you are in copyright violation. Please remove it immediately.
Susan Maneck
Dear Rajah
It is very strange that Susan does not permit the others to find the Truth.
Dear azaraf,
It is even more strange that you are using this alleged basis of “Truth” as a means by which anyone may circumvent copyright laws. That makes you an ideological fundamentalist morally, and a criminal legally.
I am not neither the writer or the manager of the said weblog nor its speaker!!
But “Internet” is a worldwide and open and free space to all.
Let the people to find the ” Thruths “without any limitation and sensorship!!!!
I never said you were the writer or the manager.
Well in that case, how about we take turns and start putting up *all* the copyrighted books we find on Amazon and elsewhere so that people will find “the Truth” and to heck with the authors and their royalties!
There is a REASON why the government tries to protect the rights of the publishers by establishing copyright laws.
Religion and whatever you make of it is NEVER an excuse to break temporal laws. I bet to some Mormons, practicing polygamy leads to a better lifestyle or something, but just because that’s one of their values doesn’t make it okay to engage in the act – polygamy is forbidden in America.
In brief, there would be no issue here if Rajah had gained Susan’s permission before posting her article on his blog, which he evidently did not do as evidenced by Susan’s warning. That means he is in violation of a copyright law. Whether or not you think that’s a preclusion of finding the Truth is irrelevant in legal circumstances, and it would make you an ideological fundamentalist morally, as I stated earlier.
[...] Women In The Bahaism [...]
Mr Adib
Instead of acuusing the others please answer the violation of the legal and natural right of bahai women who are not allowed to be a member of UHJ
Dear Yaqub,
It is presumptuous of you to assume that Baha’u'llah had no wisdom in his injuction of (perhaps temporarily) debarring women from the highest institution of the Faith. In case you’ve forgotten, Bahiyyih Khanum led the faith by herself for 8 months before Shoghi Effendi took the reins.
Also, the “Supreme Tribunal” and the House might merge – and there’s nothing debarring women from the former instituition.
Meditate on that one.
Dear Adib
– It is very strange that usually your explanations will bring more questions !!
Firstly why Shoghi did not take the reins immediately after the death of Abdulbaha ?
Secondly who asked or ordered Bahiyyah to lead the Bahai Faith and what was her position there?
Dear Yaqub,
I don’t find it strange at all; I’m glad to have elicited some curiosity in you. There’s nothing wrong with asking fair questions.
I do not think anyone asked and certainly did not order Bahiyyih Khanum to lead the Faith for those 8 months, she did so on her own (Shoghi obviously had no problem with that).
But why did she step in and not Shoghi immediately, as you asked? Well, imagine that you are man only 23 or 24 years of age and you are now supposed to lead an entire religion. Don’t you think that would have been rather overwhelming for him? Well in reality, it was. That’s why during those 8 months or so, Shoghi Effendi retreated to the Swiss Alps for meditation and reflection on what he would be doing during his ministry – a period of time which would come to last 36 years.
I was incorrect, my apologies; I just read in “The Prophet’s Daughter” that Shoghi Effendi asked Bahiyyih Khanum to take the reins until he returned from the Alps.
How strange is your story-telling , if what you are telling is true it is in clear contradiction to the will of Abdol-baha !!!
In what way? Please do tell.
How the bahai faith can explain an eight month gap in leadership of bahaism !
First of all Yaqub jan, you have not explained how this situation contradicts `Abdu’l-Baha’s Will and Testament. You made this allegation, therefore the burden of proof lies on you.
Secondly, “explaining” this 8-month period is very easy, and I have already done it – no “contradictions” attached. `Abdu’l-Baha died and Shoghi Effendi then became his successor, but Shoghi was a very young adult of 23-24 at the time, and being entrusted with the task of leading a global religious community for the remainder of his life was naturally overwhelming for someone of that age, as I imagine would be the case for anyone else in his situation. Therefore, Shoghi Effendi needed some time to reflect on the situation at hand, what he would be doing during his ministry, and things of that nature – it would certainly not be prudent to jump into such a role headfirst. Thus, Shoghi retreated to the Swiss Alps for about 8 months, and he asked Bahiyyih Khanum to take his place during that period so that the Baha’i Faith could have a leader during his absence. When Shoghi Effendi returned, he began his ministry of the Baha’i Faith which would come to last until 1957.